The Best Eats in Iceland's Charming Capital: Exploring Reykjavik's Culinary Delights!

Reykjavik, the lively capital of Iceland, is a treasure trove of culinary experiences waiting for you to explore. Whether you're in the mood for snacks on the go or a full dining experience where every dish is a work of art, the city offers an impressive range of options. You can find traditional Icelandic dishes as well as modern twists that cater to every taste. Get ready for a delightful food journey as we uncover the flavors that make Reykjavik shine!

In this post, we will examine diverse dining offerings, from casual eateries to fine dining, while highlighting average prices, must-try dishes, and their locations. Let’s grab a fork and dive into the delicious world of Reykjavik!

Bookmark these other reads for later:

This blog may include affiliate links, meaning if you buy something through one of our links, I could earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate links help sustain our blog and allow us to continue traveling. Thank you for your support!

Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur

No visit to Reykjavik is complete without stopping at Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur, often celebrated as the best hot dog in Reykjavik. Established in 1937, this humble eatery has won the hearts of both locals and visitors. The hot dogs, made from a mix of lamb, pork, and beef, deliver a unique flavor profile that is a must-have.

Must-Try Dish: The "eina með öllu" (one with everything) hot dog, topped with crispy fried onions, sweet brown mustard, and Icelandic remoulade. It's to die for!

Man in blue jacket eats a hot dog outdoors. He's holding a napkin. Background includes red bins and people sitting. Casual setting. — Ryan enjoying his hot dog on our first day in Reykjavik

Average Price: 500 ISK (around $4).

Location: Located near the Old Harbour at Tryggvagata 1, it’s just a short walk from the Harpa Concert Hall and the Sun Voyager sculpture.

Islenski Barinn

If you’re feeling adventurous, head to Islenski Barinn for a taste of traditional Icelandic cuisine. Specializing in wild game and fresh seafood, this charming restaurant combines rustic decor with a cozy atmosphere, perfect for winding down after a busy day.

This is the first restaurant we tried in Iceland on our first trip in 2017, so of course we came back in 2024 on our most recent trip! The food was just as delicious as we remember. We highly recommend the reindeer burger with sweet potato fries!

We both ordered reindeer burgers - they're that good!

Must-Try Dish: The reindeer burger is both flavorful and unique, offering a rich game meat experience, complete with homemade sauces that enhance its taste.

Average Price: 2,900 ISK (approximately $22).

Location: Found at Laugavegur 12, this spot is just a stone's throw from the iconic Hallgrímskirkja church.

Snaps Bistro

Snaps Bistro delivers a lively dining experience with its French-inspired menu. This bistro focuses on using fresh, local ingredients, and its inviting atmosphere makes it a popular destination.

Must-Try Dish: The moules frites is a standout dish, featuring fresh mussels simmered in white wine, served alongside crispy, golden fries.

Average Price: 3,500 ISK (approximately $27).

Location: Situated at Þórsgata 1, Snaps Bistro is close to the vibrant Laugavegur shopping district, making it an ideal stop for shoppers.

Grillmarkaðurinn (The Grill Market)

For an upscale dining experience infused with Icelandic flair, visit Grillmarkaðurinn. This modern eatery showcases an array of local meats and seafood cooked on the grill, with menus that celebrate seasonality.

Must-Try Dish: The grilled lamb is tender and aromatic, accompanied by seasonal vegetables that complement its flavors beautifully.

Average Price: 6,500 ISK (approximately $50).

Location: Found at Lækjargata 2a, it’s just a short stroll from the city center and near the scenic Tjörnin pond.

Cafe Loki

For a taste of traditional Icelandic dishes in a friendly setting, Cafe Loki is a fantastic choice. Located adjacent to Hallgrímskirkja, this café is known for its warm hospitality and emphasis on local specialties. Plus, you'll have a great view of the church while enjoying your food.

Must-Try Dish: The Icelandic platter offers a bite-sized showcase of local flavors, including rye bread, herring, and the adventurous fermented shark (hákarl).

Average Price: 2,400 ISK (about $18).

Location: Just a quick walk from Hallgrímskirkja at Lokastígur 1 , it's a convenient spot for lunch after sightseeing.

Fish Market (Fiskmarkaðurinn)

Seafood lovers will be delighted by the offerings at Fish Market, where fresh and sustainably sourced dishes come to life in a stylish setting. The restaurant features a menu that fuses Icelandic traditions with international culinary influences.

Must-Try Dish: The seafood tasting menu provides a delightful sampling of various fish prepared in multiple styles, showcasing seasonal availability.

Average Price: 6,500 ISK (approximately $50).

Location: Position at Vesturgata 2a, it’s a short walk from the Harpa Concert Hall, making it a perfect dining destination after an event.

Icelandic Street Food

If you’re after casual dining and more affordable prices, Icelandic Street Food offers gourmet takes on beloved Icelandic dishes! Their fast-food concept prioritizes quality, ensuring delicious food without any compromise.

Must-Try Dish: The lamb soup in a bread bowl is hearty and ideal for warming up on colder days.

Average Price: 2,300 ISK (around $17).

Location: Located at Lækjargata 4, it is conveniently close to both the Sun Voyager and Harpa Concert Hall.

Matur og Drykkur

Celebrating traditional Icelandic cuisine, Matur og Drykkur uses classic recipes with a modern twist. The restaurant’s rustic charm makes it an inviting space for those looking to appreciate authentic flavors.

Must-Try Dish: The fish stew is rich and comforting, featuring local fish in a creamy broth that warms the soul.

Average Price: 5,000 ISK (roughly $38).

Location: Located at Grandagardur 2, it's near the waterfront and just a short walk from the beautiful Ásmundarsafn Sculpture Museum.

With its colorful and diverse food scene, Reykjavik is a culinary paradise that offers flavors for every budget and preference. From iconic hot dog stands to elegant dining establishments, there is no shortage of delicious experiences to discover. When you visit, indulge in local dishes and embrace the culinary heritage that shapes this charming capital.

The selections listed here are only the beginning of what you can find in Reykjavik. Enjoy your food adventure through the city, and don’t miss savoring the vibrant atmosphere that accompanies each meal. As you explore these eateries, take in the stunning landscapes and the rich culture of Iceland, creating memories that will last long after the plates are cleared. Happy dining in Reykjavik!

Now that you have the best places to eat in mind, check out some of the best sites in the city here!